To What Extent Is The Turner Thesis Valid

To What Extent Is The Turner Thesis Valid-78
The most unusual features of that environment were "the existence of an area of free land its continuous recession, and the advance of American settlement westward." This free land served as a magnet to draw men westward, attracted by the hope of economic gain or adventure.

The most unusual features of that environment were "the existence of an area of free land its continuous recession, and the advance of American settlement westward." This free land served as a magnet to draw men westward, attracted by the hope of economic gain or adventure.

This problem was still much in his mind when he returned to the University of Wisconsin as an instructor in 1889.

In two remarkable papers prepared during the next few years he set forth his answer.

This was Turner's famous "frontier hypothesis." For a generation after its enunciation its persuasive logic won uncritical acceptance among historians, but beginning in the late 1920's, and increasingly after Turner's death in 1932, an avalanche of criticism steadily mounted.

His theories, critics said, were contradictory, his generalizations unsupported, his assumption inadequately based: what empirical proof could he advance, they asked, to prove that the frontier experience was responsible for American individualism, mobility, or wastefulness?

Complex political institutions were unnecessary in a tiny frontier outpost; traditional economic practices were useless in an isolated community geared to an economy of self -sufficiency; rigid social customs were outmoded in a Land where prestige depended on skill with the axe or rifle rather than on hereditary glories; cultural pursuits were unessential in a land where so many material tasks awaited doing.

Hence in each pioneer settlement there occurred a rapid reversion to the primitive.

John de Crevecoeur in the eighteenth century: "What then is the American, this new mail?

" Was that composite figure actually a "new man" with unique traits that distinguished him from his Old World ancestors? The most widely accepted-and bitterly disputed-answer was advanced by a young Wisconsin historian named Frederick Jackson Turner in 1893.

The American was a new man, he held, who owed his distinctive characteristics and institutions to the unusual New World environment-characterized by the availability of free land and an ever-receding frontier in which his civilization bad grown to maturity.

This environmental theory, accepted for a generation after its enunciation, has been vigorously attacked and vehemently defended during the past two decades. Is it still a valid key to the meaning of American history?

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments To What Extent Is The Turner Thesis Valid

  • FREDERICK JACKSON TURNER - CiteSeerX - Penn State
    Reply

    Jackson Turner, Frontier Thesis, Postsecondary Teaching Techniques. A basic form of valid, coherent analysis using a logical process that. to what extent, Turner should be considered a contemporary practitioner in the.…

  • Turner in the Tropics The Frontier Concept Revisited - Zenodo
    Reply

    His major proposition – the famous “Turner thesis” or “frontier hypothesis” proper. institutions, democratic to an extent the professor thought was unequalled by any. While a first strand of critique thus questioned the validity of the proposed.…

  • The Significance of the Frontier in American History.
    Reply

    Historian Frederick Jackson Turner presented this paper to a special meeting of the American Historical Association at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in.…

  • How The Frontier Shaped The American Character.
    Reply

    Is it still a valid key to the meaning of American history. historical hypothesis in the famous essay on “The Significance of the Frontier in American History. realized felt the frontier's impact, but that does not minimize the extent of the impact.…

  • The West as History The Turner Thesis United States History II
    Reply

    The young Wisconsin historian Frederick Jackson Turner presented his “frontier thesis,” one of the most influential theories of American history, in his essay.…

  • Frederick Jackson Turner
    Reply

    And R. A. Billington, ed. The Frontier Thesis Valid Interpretation of American. In the discussion of its extent, its westward movement, etc. it can not.…

  • How the Frontier Shaped the American Character
    Reply

    Is it still a valid key to the meaning of American history. historical hypothesis in the famous essay on "The Significance of the Frontier in American History. realized felt the frontier's impact, but that does not minimize the extent of the impact.…

  • The Significance of Frederick Jackson Turner's Frontier Thesis
    Reply

    The Life of an Idea The Significance of Frederick Jackson Turner's Frontier Thesis. Society is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Montana. Jackson Turner's brief essay, "The Signifi-. a valid reason for this.…

  • Revisiting the Vanishing Frontier The Legacy of Frederick.
    Reply

    With JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Western Historical Quarterly. No less familiar than the Turner thesis itself, of course, are the com-. Valid Interpretation of American History? New York, 1966;.…

The Latest from valery-designer.ru ©