Substance Dualism Essays

Substance Dualism Essays-13
Secondly he seems to forget that we only have one tongue as a sense organ.Zinn (1749) argued that the brain is fully divisible after split brain experiments on dogs.

Secondly he seems to forget that we only have one tongue as a sense organ.Zinn (1749) argued that the brain is fully divisible after split brain experiments on dogs.

If the mental is non-physical then how can it ‘cause’ anything to occur?

Rather like a ghost riding a bike it seems as though the mind is causally impotent. I am thinking about taking a sip of Green tea and Jasmine as I write.

As a DVD has soundtracks and visual files the world we experience has mental thoughts and physical activities or actions which coincide at the same time though are not causally linked.

It is as though these two separate tracks run in parallel.

The justification of the sceptical method of doubting is too shaky to accept.

The second issue we have is the issue of interactionism.The logical problem arising from this was his contention that the mind could be separate from the body.He employed the method of doubting but did not believe that he could deny his mind because he was thinking (cogito ergo sum – “I think, therefore I am”).The body was matter and all matter was simply extension, inertia moved by other things or describable in terms of space, depth, distance or length.This res extensa required something else to move it.Although one might argue that a dog’s mind or brain is radically different from a human’s leaving Zinn’s work to be irrelevant in this case.However, the Functionalist Putnam might argue that (at least in terms of pain) we are similar enough in experiences for this criticism to stand.The specification does mention ‘other concepts of the body/soul distinction;’ and this is where Descartes would be relevant along with ‘questions surrounding the nature of disembodied existence;’. When assessing Descartes’ view of the soul there are a number of issues which need addressing.The first is the logical problems which arise from his original thoughts, the second the problem of interactionism, and the third is the problem of Descartes’ grammar which all go towards demonstrating that a Cartesian view of the soul is philosophically weak. Descartes was a substance dualist and a product of the renaissance. Wiley Online Library requires cookies for authentication and use of other site features; therefore, cookies must be enabled to browse the site.Detailed information on how Wiley uses cookies can be found in our Privacy Policy.

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments Substance Dualism Essays

The Latest from valery-designer.ru ©